Part One
Social and Intellectual Basis
of Worker-communism
A better world
To
change the world and to create a better one has always been a
profound aspiration of people throughout human history. It is
true that even the present-day so-called modern world is dominated
by fatalistic ideas, religious as well as non- religious, which
portray the present plight of humanity as somehow given and inevitable.
Nevertheless the actual lives and actions of people themselves
reveal a deep-seated belief in the possibility and even the certainty
of a better future. The hope that tomorrow's world can be free
of today's
inequalities, hardships and deprivations, the belief that people
can, individually and collectively, influence the shape of the
world to come, is a deep-rooted and powerful outlook in society
that guides the lives and actions of vast masses of people.
Worker-communism,
first and foremost, belongs here, to the unshakable belief of
countless people and successive generations that building a better
world and a better future by their own hands is both necessary
and possible.
Freedom, equality, prosperity
Clearly,
everyone's image of an ideal world is not one and the same. However,
throughout human history certain ideas have always come to the
fore as the measures of human happiness and social progress, so
much so that they are today part and parcel of the political vocabulary
worldwide as sacred principles. Freedom, equality, justice and
prosperity are the first among them.
Precisely
these ideals form the intellectual foundations of worker-communism.
Worker-communism is a movement for changing the world and setting
up a free, equal, human and prosperous society.
Class struggle: proletariat and bourgeoisie
However,
worker-communists are not a bunch of utopian reformers and heroic
saviours of humanity. Communist society is not a fantastic design
or recipe conceived by well-wishing know-alls. Worker-communism
is a social movement arising from within modern capitalist society
itself, a movement that reflects the vision, ideals and protest
of a vast section of this same society.
The history of all societies to date has been a history of class
struggle. An uninterrupted, now open and now hidden, struggle
has been going on between exploiting and exploited, oppressor
and oppressed classes in different epochs and societies. This
class struggle is the chief source of social change and transformation.
Earlier societies were built on a complex hierarchy of classes
and strata. Modern capitalist society, however, has greatly simplified
class divisions. For all the variety of occupations and the extensive
division of labour in it, the present society as a whole is organised
around two main opposing class camps: workers and capitalists,
proletariat and bourgeoisie.
The opposition of these two camps is, at the most fundamental
level, the source of all the multiplicity of economic, political,
intellectual and cultural conflicts going on in the existing society.
Not only society's political and economic life, but also the cultural,
intellectual and scientific life of humanity today - areas which
appear to be independent domains standing above and independent
of classes - bear the imprint of this central alignment in the
modern capitalist society. The camp of the proletariat, of workers,
for all the variety of thoughts, ideals, tendencies and parties
in it, represents the will to change the system in favour of the
oppressed and the poor. The camp of the bourgeoisie, again for
all its various strands of thought, political parties, thinkers
and leaders, stands for the preservation of the status quo and
the protection of the capitalist system and the economic and political
power and privileges of the bourgeoisie, in the face of workers'
drive for freedom and equality.
Worker-communism emerges out of this class struggle. It belongs
to the camp of the proletariat. Worker-communism is the revolutionary
movement of the working class for overthrowing the capitalist
system and creating a new society without classes and exploitation.
Worker-communism
However,
not only freedom and equality, but even the ideal of abolishing
classes and exploitation are not unique to worker- communism.
These goals have been the watchword of other movements and other
oppressed classes in earlier societies too. What distinguishes
worker-communism as a movement is the fact that it emerges in
opposition to capitalism, i.e. the latest and most modern class
system.
Worker-communism is the social movement of the proletariat, a
class that is itself a product of capitalism and modern industrial
production, and the main exploited class in this system. It is
a class that lives by the sale of its labour power and has no
other means of making a living but its labour power. The proletariat
is not a slave, not a serf, not an artisan; it is neither owned
by anyone, nor does it own its means of production. It is both
free and forced to sell its labour power in the market to capital.
The principles and social ideals of worker-communism derive from
a criticism of the economic, social and intellectual foundations
of capitalism. This is a criticism from the standpoint of the
wage-earning working class in this society, and thereby thorough
and revolutionary. The working people's conception of freedom,
equality and human happiness is, and has always been in previous
societies, inevitably a reflection of the existing social relations
and of their own position vis- a-vis production and property.
The slave's conception of freedom did not go much beyond abolition
of slavery, and the serf's and urban artisan's conception of equality
could not be anything more than equality in property rights. But
with the rise of the proletariat, as the great mass of producers
free from any form of ownership of means of production, a class
whose economic bondage and exploitation is precisely based on
its legal freedom, the concept of freedom and equality changed
fundamentally. The proletariat cannot set itself free, without
society as such being set free from class divisions and private
ownership of means of production. Equality is not just a juridical
notion, but also, and fundamentally, an economic and social one.
With Marxism the proletarian criticism of capitalism and the worker-communist
movement and social outlook which had emerged with the Industrial
Revolution, attained immense coherence clarity and theoretical
vigour . The worker-communist movement has since been inseparably
linked with Marxism and the Marxist critique of political economy
of the capitalist society
Worker-communism is a social movement that came into existence
with the rise of capitalism and the wage-earning working class,
and represents the deepest and most universal working- class criticism
of capitalism and its ills. The objectives and practical programme
of this movement are based on the Marxist critique of the foundations
of contemporary capitalism, i.e. the last, most modern and most
advanced form of class society.
Worker-communism is not a movement separate from the working class.
It has no interests apart from those of the working class as a
whole. What distinguishes this movement from the other workers'
movements and parties is that, firstly, in the class struggles
in various countries it champions the unity and common interests
of the workers of the entire world, and, secondly, in the various
stages and fronts of workers' struggles it represents the interests
of the working class as a whole. Thus, worker-communism is the
movement of the most advanced section of the working class which
understands the ultimate goal and the conditions and pre-requisites
of victory and tries to rally the various sections of the working
class.
Capitalism
A balance-sheet
The
capitalist system is behind all the ills that burden humanity
today. Poverty, deprivation, discrimination, inequality, political
repression, ignorance, bigotry, cultural backwardness, unemployment,
homelessness, economic and political insecurity, corruption and
crime are all inevitable products of this system. No doubt bourgeois
apologists would rush to tell us that these have not been invented
by capitalism, but have all existed before capitalism, that exploitation,
repression, discrimination, women's oppression, ignorance and
prejudice, religion and prostitution are more or less as old as
human society itself.
What is being covered up here is the fact that, firstly, all these
problems have found a new meaning in this society, corresponding
to the needs of capitalism. These are being constantly reproduced
as integral parts of the modern capitalist system. The source
of poverty, starvation, unemployment, homelessness and economic
insecurity at the end of the 20th century is the economic system
in place at the end of the 20th century. The brutal dictatorships,
wars, genocides and repressions that define the life of hundreds
of millions of people today draw their rationale from the needs
of the system that rules the world today and serve specific interests
in this world. Women's oppression today is not the result of medieval
economy and morality, but a product of the present society's economic
and social system and moral values.
Secondly, it is the bourgeoisie and the capitalist system itself
that continually and relentlessly resists people's effort to eradicate
and overcome these ills. The obstacle to workers' struggle to
improve living conditions and civil rights is none other than
the bourgeoisie and its governments, parties and apologists. Wherever
people rise in the poorer regions to take charge of their lives,
the first barrier they face is the armed force of the local and
international bourgeoisie. It is the bourgeoisie's state, its
enormous media and propaganda machinery, institution of religion,
traditions, moralities and educational system which shape the
backward and prejudiced mentalities among successive generations.
There is no doubt that it is capitalism and the bourgeoisie who
stand in the way of the attempt by millions of people, driven
to the edges and more or less clear about the outlines of a society
worthy of human beings, to change the system.
Today at the end of the 20th century, at the height of capitalism's
globalization and in the midst of the greatest technological revolutions,
humanity finds itself in one of the most critical periods of its
history. Bare physical survival has become the main challenge
for millions of people, from the impoverished countries of Africa
and Asia to capital cities of the West. For the more backward
countries, the hope of economic development has now been totally
shattered. The dream of economic growth has given way to the permanent
nightmare of famine, starvation and disease. In the advanced Europe
and the USA, following years of recession, the miserable promise
of "growth without employment" holds the same nightmarish
prospect for tens of millions of working-class families. Around
the world, war and genocide are wreaking havoc. Massive intellectual
and cultural U-turns are in progress: from the resurgence of religious
fanaticism, male-chauvinism, racism, tribalism and fascism to
the collapse of the individual's rights and status in society,
to the abandoning of the life and livelihood of millions, old
and young, at the mercy of the free market. In most countries,
organised crime has become a permanent fact of life and an integral
part of society's economic and political functioning. Drug addiction
and the growing power of criminal networks engaged in the production
and trafficking of drugs is now a major unsolvable international
problem. The capitalist system and the primacy of profit have
exposed the environment to serious dangers and irreparable damages.
Bourgeois thinkers and analysts do not even claim to have an answer
to these problems. This is the reality of capitalism today, boding
a horrifying future for the entire people of the world.
Foundations of capitalism
The
present society is no doubt complex and sophisticated. Billions
of people are in continuous interaction in elaborate arrays of
economic, social and political relations. Technology and production
have acquired gigantic dimensions. Humanity's intellectual and
cultural life, just as its problems and difficulties, are broad
and diverse. But these complexities only keep out of sight simple
and comprehendible realities that make up the economic and social
fabric of the capitalist world.
Like any other class system, capitalism is based on the exploitation
of direct producers - the appropriation of a part of the product
of their labour by the ruling classes. The specific character
of every social system in different historical epochs lies in
the particular way in which this exploitation in each system takes
place. Under slavery not only the slave's product but he himself
belonged to the slave- owner. He worked for the slave-owner, and
in return was kept alive by him. In the feudal system the peasants
either handed over part of their produce to the feudal lord, or
performed certain hours of forced and unpaid labour. Under capitalism,
however, exploitation has quite different bases.
Here the main producers, i.e. the workers, are free; they don't
belong to anyone, are not appendages of any estate, they are in
bondage of any lord. They own and control their own body and labour
power. But workers are also "free" in yet another sense:
they are `free` from the ownership of means of production, and
so in order to live, they have to sell their labour power for
a certain length of time, in exchange for wages, to the capitalist
class - i.e. a small minority that own and monopolise the means
of production. The workers have to then buy their means of subsistence
- the goods they themselves have produced - in the market from
the capitalists. The essence of capitalism and the basis of exploitation
in this system is the fact that, on the one hand, labour power
is a commodity, and, on the other hand, the means of production
are the private property of the capitalist class.
Without living human labour power that sets instruments of labour
to work and creates new products, the existence of human society,
the very survival of human beings and satisfaction of their needs,
is inconceivable. This is true of any system. But in capitalism
labour power and means of production are shut off from each other
by the wall of private property; they are commodities and their
owners must meet in a market. On the face of it, the owners of
these commodities enter into a free and equal transaction: the
worker sells his/her labour power for certain periods, in exchange
for wages, to the capitalist, i.e. the owner of the means of production;
the capitalist employs this labour power, uses it up and makes
new products. These commodities are then sold in the market and
the revenue begins the production cycle anew, as capital.
However, behind the apparently equal exchange between labour and
capital lies a fundamental inequality; an inequality which defines
the lot of humanity today and without whose elimination society
will never be free. With wages, workers only gets back what they
have sold, i.e. the ability to work and to show up in the market
once again. By its daily work the working class only ensures its
continued existence as worker, its survival as the daily seller
of labour power. But capital in this process grows and accumulates.
Labour power is a creative power; it generates new values for
its buyer. The value of the commodities and services produced
by the worker at any cycle of the production process is greater
than the worker's total share and that portion of the products
which goes into restoring the used up materials and wear and tear.
This surplus value, taking the form of an immense stock of commodities,
belongs automatically to the capitalist class, and increases the
mass of its capital, by virtue of the capitalist class's ownership
of the means of production. Labour power in its exchange with
capital only reproduces itself, while capital in its exchange
with labour power grows. The creative capacity of labour power
and the working class's productive activity reflects itself as
the birth of new capital for the capitalist class. The more and
the better the working class works, the more power capital acquires.
The gigantic power of capital in the world today and its ever-
expanding domination of the economic, political and intellectual
life of the billions of inhabitants of the earth is nothing but
the inverted image of the creative power of work and of working
humanity.
Thus, exploitation in capitalist society takes place without yokes
and shackles on the shoulders and feet of the producers- through
the medium of the market and free and equal exchange of commodities.
This is the fundamental feature of capitalism which distinguishes
it in essence from all earlier systems.
The surplus value obtained from the exploitation of the working
class is divided out among the various sections of the capitalist
class essentially through the market mechanism and also through
state fiscal and monetary policies. Profit, interest and rent
are the major forms in which the different capitals share in the
fruits of this class exploitation. The competition of capitals
in the market determines the share of each capitalist branch,
unit and enterprise.
But this is not all. This surplus pays whole cost of the bourgeoisie's
state machinery, army and administration, of its ideological and
cultural institutions, and the upkeep of all those who, through
these institutions, uphold the power of the bourgeoisie. By its
work, the working class pays the cost of the ruling class, the
ever-increasing accumulation of capital and the bourgeoisie's
political, cultural and intellectual domination over the working
class and the entire society.
With the accumulation of capital, the mass of commodities which
make up the wealth of bourgeois society grows. An inevitable result
of the accumulation process is the continual and accelerating
technological progress and rise in the mass and capacity of the
means of production which the working class sets in motion in
every new cycle of the production process. But compared to the
growth in society's wealth and productive powers, the working
class continually gets relatively poorer. Despite the gradual
and limited increase, in absolute terms, in the workers' standard
of living, the share of the working class from the social wealth
declines rapidly, and the gap between the living conditions of
the working class and the higher living standards that is already
made possible by its own work widens. The richer the society becomes,
the more impoverished a section the worker forms in it.
Technological progress and rise in labour productivity mean that
living human labour power is increasingly replaced by machines
and automatic systems. In a free and human society this should
mean more free time and leisure for all. But in capitalist society,
where labour power and means of production are merely so many
commodities which capital employs to make profits, the substitution
of humans by machines manifests itself as a permanent unemployment
of a section of the working class which is now denied the possibility
of making a living. The appearance of a reserve army of workers
who do not even have the possibility of selling their labour power
is an inevitable result of the process of accumulation of capital,
and at the same time a condition of capitalist production. The
existence of this reserve army of unemployed, supported essentially
by the employed section of the working class itself, heightens
the competition in the ranks of the working class and keeps wages
at their lowest socially possible level. This reserve army also
allows capital to more easily modify the size of its employed
work force in proportion to the needs of the market. Massive unemployment
is not a side-effect of the market, or a result of the bad policies
of some government. It is an inherent part of the workings of
capitalism and the process of accumulation of capital.
Periodic economic crises with catastrophic economic and social
consequences are an inevitable feature of the capitalist system.
These crises spring essentially from a fundamental contradiction
within the accumulation process itself: while labour is the source
of surplus value and profit, the accumulation process and the
inevitable technological progress constantly diminish the ratio
of labour power to means of production. The surplus value that
is produced, even if it grows in absolute terms, cannot normally
keep pace with the growth in the capital advanced. By the material
laws of the accumulation process itself, therefore, the rate of
profit has an inevitable tendency to fall. The ceaseless activity
to offset this tendency and maintain the rate of profit, especially
through intensifying exploitation and reducing the share of the
working class from the social wealth - paid in the form of wages,
public services, etc. - is the daily business of the capitalist
class, its various governments, and the large corps of bourgeois
economists, managers and experts worldwide.
Nevertheless, the inner contradictions of capital and the tendency
of the rate of profit to fall, assert themselves periodically
and throw the whole economic system into a deep crisis. Periods
of stagnation and crisis are not only signs and symptoms of the
intensification of capital's internal contradictions, but also
the practical mechanism for their alleviation and the reconstruction
of capital. Competition among different sections of capital grows
and many are driven to bankruptcy. The weaker capitals are knocked
out, improving the conditions of profitability for those who remain.
On the other hand, the capitalist class and its states embark
on a wide-scale offensive on workers' living standards. The ranks
of the unemployed swell and the exploitation of the whole working
class intensifies.
Capital emerges from every crisis more centralised. Thus the next
crisis takes on wider and deeper dimensions and gives rise to
a more severe competition and conflict in the capitalist class.
Each new crisis makes an ever more comprehensive reconstruction
of capital necessary. Equally, the prospects for society each
time grow darker and more terrifying.
The consequences of the capitalist system's contradictions and
crises are not confined to the economic sphere. Devastating global
and regional wars, militarism and military aggressions, autocratic
and police states, stripping people, and especially workers, of
their civil and political rights, rise of state terrorism, resurgence
of the extreme Right and of religious, nationalist, racist and
anti-woman groups and trends - these are the realities of contemporary
capitalism especially in periods of crisis.
State and political superstructure
Bourgeois
analysts portray the state as a necessary institution for the
administration of society in the common interest of all; an institution
supposedly embodying the collective will of the people and enforcing
their combined power. We are told that the existing laws are a
collection of self-evident natural principles, accepted by all,
which the state guarantees and puts into force. Representing the
state as an autonomous body standing above antagonistic class
interests is a cornerstone of bourgeois ideology. This idea is
more entrenched among people in advanced Western countries which
have had more stable parliamentary systems. But even in the less
developed countries, despite the existence of autocratic and police
states and the public's distrust of the existing states, the idea
of the necessity of the state is not questioned, and viewing the
state as an institution responsible for the management of society
is just as deeply rooted. The expansion of the economic role of
states, and, particularly, state intervention in the domain of
public services and economic management and control, over the
past few decades, has greatly strengthened these illusions.
The truth is that the state is the most important instrument of
the ruling class to hold the exploited masses in subjugation.
Historically, the emergence of the state has been the result of
the appearance of exploitation and division of society into exploiting
and exploited classes. For all the complexity in the structure
of present-day states, the state, as before, is an apparatus of
coercion, with the army, courts, and prisons making up its foundations.
The state is the organised coercive power of the ruling class.
It is an instrument of class rule. Any state, whatever its form
and outward appearance - a monarchy or a republic, parliamentary
or despotic - is the instrument of dictatorship of the ruling
class or classes.
In all systems, even in the most brutal slaveries of ancient times
where the class character of the state was unconcealed, the ruling
class has always needed to give some form of legitimacy to its
state. Monarchy and dynastic rule, reign of aristocracy, divine
rule and theocracy, are all forms in which such legitimacy has
been sought. In capitalist society, a society based on market,
and where worker and capitalist are portrayed as "free"
agents entering into a voluntary and equal contract, the right
to vote, the parliament and the electoral system are the chief
forms of gaining legitimacy for the class rule of the bourgeoisie.
On the surface, the state is an instrument of political rule by
all the people formed by their own direct vote. Certainly, from
a historical viewpoint, the right to vote and parliament are important
gains in the struggle of the working people to promote their civil
rights. It is also clear that life in a liberal bourgeois system
is far more tolerable than life under a military or autocratic
regime. But these forms cannot conceal the class nature of the
modern state. Even in the most advanced, stable and free parliamentary
systems the working people have very little chance of influencing
state policies and actions. Parliamentary system employs relatively
less open and brutal violence and lets government positions alternate
among different sections of the ruling class through periodic
general elections. It has thus managed to ensure the unquestionable
rule of the whole bourgeoisie over society's political and economic
life. Parliamentary democracy is not a mechanism for people's
participation in political power. It is a means of legitimizing
the rule and dictatorship of the bourgeois class.
Culture, ideology, morality
Flagrant
exploitation, discrimination and disenfranchisement of people
on such monstrous scales, could obviously not last without the
victims themselves submitting to it and rationalizing it in their
minds. To paint this state of affairs as legitimate, natural and
eternal, and to intimidate people into submission is the task
of the intellectual, cultural and moral superstructure in this
society. The cultural and intellectual arsenal of the bourgeoisie
against freedom and liberation is enormous. In part this is a
legacy of antiquity, now polished up and adapted to the needs
of bourgeois society. All shades of religions, prejudices, tribalism,
racism and male-chauvinism have throughout history served as so
many intellectual and cultural weapons in the hands of ruling
classes to hold down and silence the working people. And in our
day all of these, in new forms and capacities, are summoned to
protect bourgeois property and bourgeois rule from menace of working
peoples awareness and consciousness.
But bourgeois society's own additions to this collection of intellectual
and cultural artillery are much more extensive and efficient.
In this society, self-interest and competition, i.e. the rationale
behind the capitalist's behaviour in the market, are portrayed
as human nature as such and sanctified as exalted human values.
Here the relations among people are a reflection and an extension
of the relations among commodities. People's worth and status
are measured by their relation to ownership. The bourgeoisie broke
up the local and narrow arrangement of the old society and organised
nation- states. Tribalism and parochialism gave way to modern
bourgeois nationalism and patriotism as the heaviest ideological
yoke ever put on the shoulders of the working people.
The ruling ideas in every society are the ideas of ruling class.
But the extent of intellectual, cultural and moral domination
and control of the bourgeoisie over the life of society today
is unprecedented in history. The scientific, technical and industrial
revolutions of the past couple of centuries and the powerful mechanism
of the market, which transcends all national, tribal, political
and cultural barriers, have provided the bourgeoisie with enormous
possibilities for safeguarding its ideological rule and spreading
it on a world scale.
Just as in the sphere of production of goods, so in the sphere
of production of ideas humanity's creative power has turned into
a weapon against itself. The many innovations and advances of
the twentieth century, which have revolutionised literary and
artistic forms and means of mass communication and opened up new
fields of cultural activity, have above all paved the way for
a constant bombardment of millions of people with bourgeois ideas
in more elaborate, subtle and effective forms. The information
technology and satellite TV networks introduced over the past
two decades, which have greatly facilitated the task of information
gathering and transfer across the globe, have in the hands of
the bourgeoisie turned into a monstrous machinery of misinformation,
indoctrination and provocation. The mass media and show business,
in themselves among the most profitable sectors for capital, have
taken over a large part of the traditional role of family, religion
and even the repressive organs of the state, and play an increasing
role in preserving the existing ideological balance in society,
spreading the ideas and values of the ruling class, indoctrinating
and controlling minds, intimidating and atomizing people and countering
critical ideas and tendencies in society. These institutions and
the modern forms of thought- control are pillars of political
stability in bourgeois society, particularly in times of crisis,
uncertainty and popular unrest.
Struggle against the dominant reactionary ideas has always been
a permanent component of the class struggle of workers and a crucial
task of the worker-communist movement.
Social Revolution and Communism
The free communist society
It
is easy to see how the capitalist world is a world that is upside
down. The relations among commodities form the basis of the relations
among people. The daily work of billions of people to build the
world manifests itself as the growing domination of capital over
their lives. The motivating aim of economic activity is not satisfaction
of people's needs, but profitability of capital. Scientific and
technological progress, which are the key to human welfare and
well-being, translate in this system into even more unemployment
and impoverishment for hundreds of millions of workers. In a world
that has been built through cooperation and collective action,
it is competition that reigns. The economic freedom of the individual
is merely a guise hiding his unescapable compulsion to appear
in the labour market each and every day. The political freedom
of the individual is a cover for the his actual rightlessness
and lack of political influence, and a means of legitimizing the
and political rule and the state of the capitalist class. Law
is the will and interest of the ruling class made into rules binding
for all. From love and compassion to right and justice, from art
and creativity to science and truth, there is no concept in this
capitalist world that does not bear the imprint of this invertedness.
This inverted world must be put right side up. This is the task
of-worker-communism. It is the aim of workers' communist revolution.
The essence of communist revolution is abolition of private ownership
of the means of production and their conversion into common ownership
of the whole society. Communist revolution puts an end to the
class division of society and abolishes the wage-labour system.
Thus, market, exchange of commodities, and money disappear. Production
for profit is replaced by production to meet people's needs and
to bring about greater prosperity for all. Work, which in capitalist
society for the overwhelming majority is an involuntary, mechanical
and strenuous activity to earn a living, gives way to voluntary,
creative and conscious activity to enrich human life. Everyone,
by virtue of being a human being and being born into human society
will be equally entitled to all of life's resources and the products
of collective effort. From everyone according to their ability,
to everyone according to their need - this is a basic principle
of communist society.
Not only class divisions but also the division of people according
to occupation will disappear. All fields of creative activity
will be opened up to all. The development of each person will
be the condition of development of the society. Communist society
is a global society. National boundaries and divisions will disappear
and give way to a universal human identity. Communist society
is a society free of religion, superstitious beliefs, ideology
and archaic traditions and moralities that strangle free thought.
The disappearance of classes and class antagonisms makes the state
superfluous. In communist society the state withers away. Communist
society is a society without a state. The administrative affairs
of the society will be managed by the cooperation, consensus and
collective decision-making of all of its members.
Thus it is in the communist society that the ideals of human freedom
and equality are truly realised for the first time. Freedom not
only from political oppression but from economic compulsion and
subjugation and intellectual enslavement. Freedom to enjoy and
experience life in its diverse dimensions. Equality not only before
the law but in the enjoyment of society's material and intellectual
wealth. Equality in worth and dignity for everyone in society.
Communist society is not a dream or utopia. All the conditions
for the formation of such a society have already created within
the capitalist world itself. The scientific, technological and
productive powers of humanity have already grown so enormously
that founding a society committed to the well-being of all is
perfectly feasible. The spectacular advances in communication
and information technology during the last two decades have meant
that the organization of a world community with collective participation
in the design, planning and execution of society's diverse functions
is possible more than ever before. A large part of these resources
is now either wasted in different ways or is even deliberately
used to hinder efforts to improve society and satisfy human needs.
But for all the immensity of society's material resources, the
backbone of communist society is the creative and living power
of billions of men and women beings freed from class bondage,
wage-slavery, intellectual slavery, alienation and degradation.
The free human being is the guarantee for the realization of communist
society.
Communist society is not a utopia. It is the goal and result of
the struggle of an immense social class against capitalism; a
living, real and ongoing struggle that is as old as bourgeois
society itself. Capitalism itself has created the great social
force that can materialise this liberating prospect. The staggering
power of capital on a global scale is a reflection of the power
of a world working class. Unlike other oppressed classes in the
history of human society, the working class cannot set itself
free without freeing the whole of humanity. Communist society
is the product of workers' revolution to put an end to the system
of wage-slavery; a social revolution which inevitably transforms
the entire foundation of the production relations.
Proletarian revolution and workers' state
The
exponents and ideologues of the bourgeoisie accuse Marxism and
worker-communism of advocating force and violence to achieve their
social objectives. The truth, however, is that it is the bourgeois
system itself that is founded on organised violence; violence
against people, against their bodies and minds, against their
thoughts and emotions, against their hopes and aspirations and
against their struggle to improve their lives and the world they
live in.
The wage-labour system, that is the daily compulsion of the great
majority of people to sell their physical and intellectual abilities
to others in order to make a living, is the source and essence
of the violence which is inherent of this system. This naked violence
has many direct victims: Women, workers, children, the aged, people
of the poorer regions of the world, anyone who asks for their
rights and stands up to any oppression, and anyone who has been
branded as belonging to this or that "minority". In
this system, thanks essentially to the rivalry of capitals and
economic blocs, war and genocide have assumed staggering proportions.
The technology of war and mass destruction is far more advanced
than the technology used in production of goods. The bourgeoisie's
global arsenal can annihilate the world several times over. This
is the system that has actually used horrendous nuclear and chemical
weapons against people. Bourgeois society can also take pride
in its remarkable advances in turning crime, murder, abuse and
rape into a routine fact of life in this system.
Can such a system be swept out of the way of human liberation
and a permanent end to violence without the working people resorting
to force? Nowhere in communist theory is use of force viewed as
an necessary component of workers' revolution. But anyone with
even the slightest grasp of the realities of this society would
admit that the ruling class will never peacefully stand aside
and bow to the will of the overwhelming majority to change the
system. If protection of the day to day business and interest
of the bourgeoisie is the job of the state, defending the existence
of capitalism and bourgeois property is its very essence. If demands
for higher wages and free speech incur the wrath of the state,
police and the military, one can imagine the kind of resistance
that will be put up to the attempt to expropriate the bourgeoisie
politically and economically. Violence by the bourgeoisie and
its state against workers' revolution, against the will of the
overwhelming majority of people who, with the working class in
their lead, rise to set up a new society is practically inevitable.
Workers' revolution must bring down the bourgeois state. Bourgeois
resistance against the revolution, and particularly against the
attempt to turn the means of production into common ownership,
will continue even after bourgeois state power has been dismantled.
Therefore it is crucial to establish a workers' state that could
breaks this resistance and enforce the will of the revolution.
Like any other state, workers' state does not stand above society
and classes. It is a class rule. But this state, which accordingly
in Marxist theory has been called a dictatorship of the proletariat,
is the rule of the exploited majority to dictate to the exploiting
classes the decree of human freedom and equality and defeat their
attempts and intrigues. In its form, workers' state is a free
state which organises the direct decisions and will of the masses
of the working people themselves. By its nature, workers' state
is a transient state withers away as soon as the aims of the revolution
have been realised.
The communist party and the communist International of the working
class
A
critical requirement for the progress and victory of workers'
social revolution is the formation of worker- communist parties
that put such a perspective before the working class and mobilise
and lead the forces of the class in this struggle. These parties
should be formed in different countries, as organizations uniting
above all the most conscious and active leaders of workers' struggles.
Capitalism is a world system, the working class is a world class,
workers' conflict with the bourgeoisie is a daily struggle on
a global scale, and socialism is an alternative that the working
class presents to the whole of humanity. The worker- socialist
movement must also be organised on a global scale. The building
of a worker-communist International, as the body uniting and leading
the workers' global struggle for socialism, is an urgent task
of the various sections of the worker-communist movement and worker-communist
parties around the world.
Worker Communism and Bourgeois Communism
For
much of the twentieth century, Marxism and communism have enjoyed
an enormous prestige within different protest and reform movements
worldwide. The universality and depth of Marx's critical thinking,
Marxism's profound humanity and egalitarianism, and the worker-communist
movement's practical influence - particularly as a result of the
workers' revolution in Russia in 1917 which turned communism into
the hope of hundreds of millions of workers throughout the world
- had the result that many non-worker and even non-socialist movements
during the twentieth century began labelling themselves as communist
and Marxist. Most of these movements had very little in common
with the basic principles of communism and Marxism, and, in reality,
only desired certain reforms and moderations within the framework
of the capitalist system.
Communism was the name adopted by the worker socialist movement
in the nineteenth century to distinguish itself from the non-revolutionary,
and even reactionary, socialism of the other classes. But in the
twentieth century even this name was abused by other movements
and classes, to the extent that it lost its distinctive meaning.
Under the general name of communism, there emerged all shades
of social tendencies which neither in their outlook, nor in their
programme, nor in their social and class origins, were related
to workers' communism and Marxism. Offshoots of this non-worker
communism, and foremost among them the bourgeois communism of
the Soviet bloc, practically turned into the official mainstream
of communism throughout much of the twentieth century. Worker-
communism was driven to the margins.
The most important bourgeois-communist tendency in the twentieth
century emerged in the Soviet Union following the derailment and
final defeat of the workers' revolution. With the October 1917
revolution, the worker-communist movement, led by the Bolsheviks,
succeeded to smash the state power of the ruling classes, set
up a workers' rule and even defeat the outright military efforts
of the defeated reaction to restore its lost power. But despite
this political victory, the Russian working class ultimately failed
to transform the production relations, i.e. abolish the wage-labour
system and turn the means of production into common ownership.
In the mid- 1920s, against a backdrop of severe economic strains
following the war and revolution, and in the absence of a clear
perspective for the socialist transformation of the economic relations,
nationalism came to dominate the politics and economic programme
of the Russian workers' party and movement. What took place in
the Stalin era was not the construction of socialism but the reconstruction
of the capitalist national economy according to a state-ist and
managed model. Instead of the ideal of common and collective ownership,
state ownership of the means of production was established. Wages,
money and the wage-labour system all remained. The failure of
the Russian working class to revolutionise the economic relations
led to the defeat of the workers' revolution as a whole. Workers'
state was replaced by a new bourgeois state with a massive bureaucracy
and military apparatus based on a state- capitalist economy.
This state model became the economic blueprint of a so-called
communist pole, entering the world stage following the derailment
of the October workers' revolution. The whole "socialism"
of bourgeois communism in the Soviet Union and the Eastern bloc
consisted of economic state-ism, replacement of the market mechanism
by planning and administrative decisions, redistribution of wealth
and a minimum level of public welfare and social services.
But the Soviet Union was not the only source of bourgeois communism
in this century. In Western Europe, offshoots of non- worker communism
sprang into existence which, while sharing fundamental elements
with the economic outlook of the communism of the Eastern bloc,
namely substitution of economic state-ism for socialism, and preservation
of the wage-labour system, criticised the Soviet experience and
held their distance from it from democratic, nationalist, humanist
and modernist standpoints. Western Marxism, Eurocommunism, the
New Left and the different branches of Trotskyism were among the
prominent tendencies of non-worker communism in Western Europe.
In the less developed countries and former colonies, nationalism
and anti-colonial leanings of the bourgeoisie and petty-bourgeoisie,
and in some cases peasant movements, formed the stuff of a new
kind of "Third Worldist" communism. The content of this
communism was economic independence, industrialization, rapid
development of the national economy according to a state-driven
and planned model, an end to the open political domination of
imperialist powers, and at times even the revival of archaic local
traditions and cultural legacies in opposition to modernism and
Western culture. The archetype of Third Worldist communism was
Maoism and Chinese Communism which deeply influenced the views
and politics of so- called communist groups in the less developed
countries.
A consequence of the rise of the different strands of non- worker
communism in the twentieth century was the serious isolation and
setback of worker-communism and Marxism. In the first place, the
basic ideas of worker-socialism and different aspects of Marxist
theory were seriously revised and misinterpreted to fit the non-socialist
and non-worker nature of these movements themselves, and this
distorted picture was presented and perceived on a global scale
as Marxism and communism. Secondly, the social and class base
of twentieth century communism was shifted from the working class
into a wide spectrum of non-worker social layers. In Western Europe
and industrialised countries, intellectuals, students, academics
and the reformist sections of the bourgeoisie itself made up the
main social milieus for the growth and political action of the
communist forces. In the so-called Third World countries, besides
these groups, poor peasants, disgruntled petty-bourgeois, and
most of all a nationalist bourgeoisie yearning for national economic
development and industrialization made up the social basis of
non-worker communism.
In the absence of an influential worker-communist tradition, the
working class for decades lacked a strong independent political
presence internationally. In Western Europe and the USA and some
countries of Latin America, workers wound up in the hands of unionism
and parties of the left wing of the ruling class itself, particularly
Social-Democracy, to such an extent that these came to be perceived
by the general public and a large section of the workers themselves
as the natural and self-evident organizations of the labour movement.
In the Soviet Union and the Eastern bloc, for small concessions
at the workplace, the working class was atomised and stripped
off political rights. In the majority of the more backward countries,
even the mere idea of building workers' parties and associations
remained a suppressed hope.
The main strands of bourgeois communism reached a deadend, one
after the other, in the last few decades. The last episode was
the spectacular disintegration of the Soviet Union and the Eastern
bloc at the end of the '80s and in the early '90s - something
the bourgeoisie euphorically called the "end of communism".
But despite the anti-communist climate of the initial years of
the '90s and the bourgeoisie's deafening cries of "the fall
of communism", and despite the enormous hardship that descended
on hundreds of millions of people throughout the world following
the collapse of the Eastern bloc, current trends point to an opening
for worker-communism to retake the political centre-stage, particularly
in the industrially advanced countries. A basic requirement for
such a development is a vigorous political and theoretical confrontation
with the various trends of bourgeois communism which will re-emerge
in different forms with the progress of the workers' movement
and growing influence of Marxism and worker-communism.
Revolution and Reform
The
immediate aim of the worker-communist party is to organise the
social revolution of the working class. A revolution that overthrows
the entire exploitative capitalist relations and puts an end to
all exploitations and hardships. Our programme is for the immediate
establishment of a communist society; a society without classes,
without private ownership of the means of production, without
wage labour and without a state; a free human society in which
all share in the social wealth and collectively decide the society's
direction and future. Communist society is possible this very
day.
But the great workers' revolution that must bring about this free
society does not happen just upon the will of the worker- communist
party. This is a vast social and class movement that has to be
organised in different aspects and forms. All kinds of barriers
must be swept out of its way. This work is the raison d'etre and
the very substance of the daily activity of the-worker-communist
party. But while the struggle for the organization of workers'
revolution is going on, everyday billions of people are struggling
to eke out a living under capitalism. The revolutionary struggle
to build a new world is inseparable from the daily effort to improve
the living conditions of the working humanity in this same world.
Worker-communism does not find organizing a revolution against
this system incompatible with the struggle to impose on capitalism
the most far-reaching reforms. On the contrary, it sees its presence
in both fronts as the vital condition of final victory. Workers'
revolution is not a revolution out of desperation or poverty.
It is a revolution relying on the consciousness and material and
moral readiness of the working class. The wider the extent of
political freedoms, economic security and social dignity of the
working class and people in general and the more progressive the
political, welfare and civil standards that have been imposed
on bourgeois society by workers' and progressive struggles, the
more prepared will be the conditions for workers' revolution,
and the more decisive and sweeping the victory of this revolution.
The worker- communist movement stands in the forefront of every
struggle to improve the social conditions and standards in favour
of people.
What distinguishes worker-communism in the struggle for reforms
from reformist movements and organizations - both working-class
and non-working class - is above all that, firstly, worker-communists
always stress the fact that complete freedom and equality cannot
be achieved through reforms. Even the most profound economic and
political reforms, by definition, leave the hateful foundations
of the existing system, namely private property, class divisions
and the wage-labour system, untouched. Besides, as the whole history
of capitalism and actual experience in different countries show,
the bourgeoisie in most cases violently resists any attempt to
push through even the slightest reforms. Also, what is won is
always temporary, vulnerable and capable of being rolled back.
While fighting for reforms, worker-communism insists on the necessity
of social revolution as the only really viable and liberating
working-class alternative.
Secondly, while defending even the smallest improvements in working
people's economic, political and cultural life, worker- communism
calls for the widest and most progressive political, civil and
welfare rights. In the struggle for reforms, our movement does
not restrict itself to demanding what the capitalist class regards
as affordable. The profit and loss accounts of businesses, or
the so-called interests of the "national economy" and
so on do not condition or restrict our demands. Our starting point
is the indisputable rights of people in our times. If such rights
as the right to health care, education, economic security, the
right to strike, direct and constant participation of people in
political life, equal rights for women, freedom from religious
encroachments, etc., are inconsistent with business profitability
and the interests of capitalism, then this only goes to prove
the need to overthrow this whole system. This is the fundamental
truth that our movements brings home to the working class and
society as a whole in the fight for reforms. Our purpose in this
struggle is not the creation of a reformed capitalism, a capitalism
"with a human face", or a "caring" capitalism.
Our aim is to force the existing system to recognise and abide
by the unquestionable rights of the working people. The rights
and demands which the bourgeoisie finds incompatible with its
survival, the working class is prepared to enforce this very day
and in the most comprehensive way.
Part Two
The
worker-communist party struggles for the complete victory of the
social revolution of the working class and the introduction of
workers' communist programme in its entirety. The worker-communist
party believes that advances of human society so far in economy,
science, technology and standards of civil life have already created
the material conditions necessary to set up a free society without
classes, exploitation and oppression, i.e. a world socialist community,
and that the working class on taking political power must introduce
its communist programme.
At the same time, as long as and where-ever capitalism prevails
the-worker-communist party also struggles for the most profound
and far-reaching political, economic, social and cultural reforms
that raise the living standard of people and their political and
civil rights to the highest possible level. These reforms, as
well as the strength and unity gained in the struggle for their
realisation, will make it easier for the working people to deliver
the final blow to the capitalist system.
Part Two of the Programme contains the main immediate demands
raised by the worker-communist party in workers' ongoing struggles
to impose reforms on the existing system. Though, by the standards
of even the most advanced capitalist countries today, the following
demands and norms appear radical and ideal, in fact they only
represent a very small fraction of rights and freedoms that will
be realised in full in a communist society.
There is no doubt that even the slightest improvement in the life
of the people in Iran today and the realization of the most elementary
rights and liberties require bringing down the inhuman and reactionary
Islamic Republic regime. The overthrow of this regime is an urgent
task of workers' revolution in Iran. The worker-communist party
struggles for the overthrow of the Islamic Republic and the immediate
establishment of workers' state. The workers' rule will not only
ensure the immediate introduction of the norms outlined in this
section of the Programme as the most basic rights of the people
in Iran but will also, by implementing the whole of its communist
programme, prepare the conditions for real and complete liberation
and equality.
General Principle and Framework
1.
Establishment of a political structure based on people's direct
and permanent participation in political power.
2.
Establishment of far-reaching, unconditional, guaranteed and equal
political and civil rights and liberties for all. Abolition of
any kind of discrimination according to sex, ethnicity, nationality,
citisenship, race, religion, age, and so on.
3.
Introduction of such general economic and welfare norms, as well
as a progressive labour law, that impose the highest standard
of living, welfare and economic security for people on the existing
capitalist system.
4.
Legislation of laws and measures to radically and swiftly push
aside reactionary, discriminatory and degrading beliefs, customs
and traditions and help the development of a free and open culture,
values and human relations.
5.
Introduction of laws and policies which turn Iran into a source
of support for progressive struggles, progressive social values
and relations, and workers' and socialist struggles around the
world.
The
above general principles to be implemented at once through the
following measures:
The Structure and Organs
of Political Power
Council rule
Our
times more than any other have brought to full view the real disenfranchisement
of the people and the formal nature of their participation in
political power under liberal and parliamentary democracies. A
society that is to ensure wide popular participation in government
and in the legislative and executive process cannot be based on
parliament and on the system of delegatory democracy. Exercise
of power at various levels, from the local up to the national
level, has to be carried out by people's own councils, acting
as both legislative and executive. The supreme ruling organ will
be the national congress of representatives of people's councils.
All persons over the age of 16 are recognised as vote-carrying
members of their local council and have the right to run for all
positions in the local council or for representation to higher
councils.
Dissolution of the army
The
army and professional armed forces in the existing society are
but the armed mercenary bands of the ruling class, organised at
the expense of the working people to keep them under subjugation
and to protect the economic interests and the home market of one
country's bourgeoisie against another. Despite the fact that the
ruling class tries to conceal the class nature and the real function
of its army under various covers, portraying it as a public organ
created to serve society as a whole, the intimate connection of
armies with ruling classes, and their role in protecting the interests
of the masters of society is clear to the majority of people -
and this not only in Asian, African and Latin American countries,
where the repressive role of the army and police has been blatantly
obvious, but also in Europe and North America, where the myth
of an apolitical military has survived longer.
The Worker-communist Party stands for the dissolusion of the army
and professional armed forces.
The army, Pasdaran (Islamic guards) and other professional armed
forces, as well as all secret military, security and espionage
organisations, should be dissolved.
A militia force of people's councils, based on universal military
education and universal participation in security and defence
duties, replaces the professional army that stands separate from
and above the people.
In addition, the party believes that the following principles
must be applied in any case and under all circumstances, whilst
armed forces exist:
Repealing the practice of unquestioning obedience in the armed
forces. All military personnel have the right to refuse to carry
out orders which they regard as being in conflict with the laws
of the country or which contradict their own conscience and principles.
Every person has the right to refuse to take part in war or in
any military activity that is incompatible with his/her principles
and beliefs.
Members of law-enforcement agencies must always wear their uniforms
on duty and bear their weapons unconcealed. Formation of armed
forces without uniform or conducting of missions as armed police
in civilian clothes is forbidden. It is the right of every citizen
to have knowledge of the presence of armed law-enforcement forces
in her community and vicinity (workplaces, residential areas,
roads, etc.).
Members of the military have the right to take part in political
activities and join political parties. Political parties, trade
unions and other organisations have freedom of activity inside
military forces.
Abolition of unelected bureaucracy. Direct popular participation
in administration
All
political and administrative organs and posts in the country are
to be elective and revokable whenever the majority of the electors
so decide. Persons elected to such posts should receive salaries
not higher than the average wage of workers. Direct supervision
by people, through their councils, of the activities of all administrative
bodies. Simplification of the hierarchy, language and working
procedures of state bureaus in order to make people's intervention
in them and their control a simple task.
Enhancement of work ethics and respect for citizens and clients
in the public service. Any abuse of position of authority by officials,
bribery, nepotism, discrimination, deviation from legally defined
rules and procedures, or failure to carry out the provisions of
law etc., should result in prosecution in common courts as major
offences. Strict prohibition of the use of facilities and resources
of public office for private purposes.
Unconditional right of individuals to sue any state official in
common courts.
An independent judiciary. Legal justice for all
The
judicial system and the concept of legal justice in every society
are a reflection of the social relations and the economic and
political foundations of that society. The judicial sphere - from
the corpus of laws and the prevailing interpretation of right,
fairness and justice, to the institutions, administration and
procedures of judicial power - is part of society's political
superstructure that protects the existing economic and class foundations.
Thus, genuine legal justice and its equal application to all,
and a truly independent and fair administration of justice, require
a fundamental refashioning of the existing class society.
As a step towards this goal, and to ensure the most equitable
judicial practice possible in the existing society, the Worker-
communist Party calls for the immediate implementation of the
following basic principles:
1
- Complete legal independence of judges, courts and the judicial
system from the executive.
2
- Judges and other judicial authorities to be elective by people,
and revokable whenever the majority of the electorate so decide.
3
- Abolition of special courts; all trials to take place in common
courts.
4
- All trials to be open and public. Trial by jury in all major
criminal offences. The right of the accused and their lawyers
to accept or reject judges or members of the jury.
5
- In all trials, the accused is presumed innocent until proven
guilty, and the burden of proof lies with the prosecutor or
the plaintiff.
6
- The country's judicial principles and the rights of the individual
before the judicial system are described in more detail in later
sections of the Programme.
Individual and Civil Rights and Liberties
Bourgeois
apologists claim that respect for individual and civil rights
is a hallmark and a linchpin of their system. The truth is that
out of the five billion or more people who live under the rule
of capital today, only a fraction, and that only in a handful
of countries, can be said to enjoy any sort of stipulated and
fairly stable individual and civil rights. The lot of the overwhelming
majority of people in the capitalist world is a more or less absolute
lack of political rights, despotic regimes and organised state
terrorism and violence. But even in the industrialised countries
of Western Europe and North America these rights are merely a
fraction of rights and liberties that people demand and deserve
today. Moreover, the economic subjugation of working people by
capital and the direct relation that exists between civil rights,
on the one hand, and property, on the other, make these rights
devoid of any real or serious meaning. Besides, the experience
of people in these countries during times of economic crisis clearly
shows that the survival of even these nominal rights directly
corresponds to the economic circumstances of the capitalist class,
and that they readily come under attack whenever they have got
in the way of profitability and accumulation of capital.
Genuine individual and civil liberties can only be realised in
a society that is itself free. By eliminating class and economic
subjugation, workers' communist revolution will open the way for
the most far-reaching freedoms and opportunities for the individual's
self-expression in the various domains of life.
At the same time, the worker-communist party struggles for the
realisation and protection of the widest individual and civil
rights in the present society. These undeniable and inviolable
rights, in their outlines, are as follows:
1
- The right to live. Immunity of body and mind against any violation.
2
- The right to a livelihood. The right to the necessaries of
a normal life in the present-day society.
3
- The right to leisure, recreation, rest and relaxation.
4
- The right to education. The right to enjoy all the educational
resources available to society.
5
- The right to health. The right to enjoy all the existing facilities
for protection against injury and disease. The right to enjoy
all health care and medical facilities available to society.
6
- The right to individual independence. Prohibition of enslavement
and forced labour under any guise or justification.
7
- The right to socialise and have a social life. Prohibition
of segregation of people from the social environment and denying
them opportunity of association with others.
8
- The right to seek and know the truth about all areas of social
life. Prohibition of censorship and control by the state or
media magnates and managers over the information made available
to the public.
9
- The right to enjoy a healthy and safe environment. The right
of people and their representatives to monitor and control the
effects on the environment of the activities of the state and
enterprises.
10
- Unconditional freedom of belief, expression, assembly, press,
demonstration, strike. unconditional freedom of organisation
and of formation of political parties.
11
- Full and unconditional freedom of criticism. The right to
criticise all political, cultural, ethical, and ideological
aspects of society. Any invocation of national, patriotic, religious
and other "sanctities" to restrict the freedom of
criticism and expression is to be prohibited and declared illegal.
Prohibition of religious, patriotic, nationalistic, and other
forms of intimidation aiming to suppress free expression of
opinion.
12
- Freedom of religion and atheism.
13
- Universal and equal suffrage for everyone over the age of
16, regardless of sex, religion, ethnicity, nationality, occupation,
citizenship, creed or political belief. The right of every person
over 16 to run for any representative body and to hold any elected
position or office.
14
- Prohibition of inquisition. The right of every person to refuse
to testify against themselves to avoid self- ncrimination. The
right to remain silent about one's personal views and beliefs.
15
- Unconditional right to choose one's place of residence. Freedom
of travel and movement for everyone over 16, man or woman. Prohibition
of any form of permanent control of movement within the country
by the state or law-enforcement authorities. Abolition of any
restrictions on exit from the country. Immediate and unconditional
issuing of passport and travel document on demand.
16
- Prohibition of imposing any restriction on the entry and exit
of citizens of other countries. Granting of citizenship to any
applicant who accepts the legal obligations of citizenship.
Unconditional issuing of residence and work permits to applicants
of residence in Iran.
17
- Inviobality of people's privacy. Inviobility of the person's
home, correspondence and conversation and its |